Agnes Borthwick

Munitions Works Manager

Photograph of Agnes Borthwick (1916?)

Credit: Reproduced by, and with permission of, the National Library of Scotland from: Official history of the Scottish Filling Factory … Georgetown (1919)

  • BORN 19th February 1889, Greenock, Inverclyde, Scotland
  • DIED 9th November 1949, Edinburgh, Scotland
  • WORKED Georgetown Shell Filling Factory, Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland
  • HONOURS Agnes Borthwick received no honours, despite her invaluable WW1 service as Works Manager of a large Munitions Factory. During a visit to the factory in October 1918, Churchill paid tribute to the “vast new army of hundreds of thousands of women workers”. Working in dangerous conditions, the women shared with soldiers some of the risks associated with the struggle, and afterwards they would share in the glory and honour of victory.
    It seems that the contribution of Agnes Borthwick was not recognised as this speech appeared to promise.

Artistic Connections

Agnes Borthwick had an arts degree, but there is no record of any artistic interests she may have possessed.  While she worked at the factory, there were opportunities for her to participate in many different cultural activities, and she may have done so.

These included:

  • The establishment of a monthly magazine, the Georgetown Gazette, which contained articles, literary contributions, drawings, sketches and photographs
  • The construction of a ‘Township Hall’ for meetings and lectures, and for entertainments such as concerts, plays, cinema showings, flower and vegetable shows, dances and dinners

Music

Title:  Agnes Borthwick – Our Garden City
Composer:  FRANCES M LYNCH
Words by: Frances M Lynch
Written: Feb 2019
For: Solo Mezzo and Speaker
Performed by: BBC singer Margaret Cameron (mezzo) and Catherine Booth (speaker)
First Performed:  Beacon Arts Centre, Greenock, Scotland March 8th 2019 as part of “ECHOES FROM INVERCLYDE” by ELECTRIC VOICE THEATRE

In this solo voice piece, AGNES BORTHWICK reflects on her time as works manager at the vast munitions factory at Georgetown in Renfrewshire during the First World War where she was in charge of more than 7,000 workers who were mainly women.
After the war, the site was flattened, despite Georgetown workers campaigning vociferously for it to be retained as a permanent garden city. They were ignored by the male politicians and post-war planners. Ironically, Churchill, who visited the factory, was once heard to say;

“A vast new army of hundreds of thousands of women workers shared with our soldiers some of the risks and burdens of the struggle, afterwards they will share some of the glory and honour of the coming victory”

Our Garden City was written for BBC Singer Margaret Cameron in collaboration with Catherine Booth – Science Curator, National Library of Scotland (retired) – both of whom appear on this recording.
The verses were originally performed interspersed with the other pieces below to create a whole scene telling the story of Agnes and the Georgetown Munitions Factory. This text can be viewed on the Soundcloud link above.

………………………….

Our standout memory at the Beacon Arts Centre show was the kids, absolutely amazing – their wee songs were amazing!! So impressed! Sandra McLaughlin & Cathy Bethel from Clydeside Singers

Title: “Georgetown Munitioneers”
Composed by: ALL SAINTS PRIMARY P6B
Words: based on poems by Geo. W Cleghorn, John Oxenham, R. H. Roberts, published in the Georgetown Gazette (1916) alongside various other extracts from anonymous articles and poems
Written in: Jan – March 2019
Arranged by: Frances M Lynch & Herbie Clarke
For: voices & guitar
Performed by: All Saints Primary P6 & Herbie Clarke (guitar)
First Performed: Beacon Arts Centre, Greenock, Scotland March 8th 2019 as part of ECHOES FROM INVERCLYDE by ELECTRIC VOICE THEATRE

This is a live recording, made at a school assembly just before the Beacon performance.
It was inspired by poems and stories published in the works magazine of the Georgetown Munitions Factory where AGNES BORTHWICK was manager. These magazines give some lively insight into life there.

YOU CAN FIND THE LYRICS OF BOTH SONGS HERE ON A PDF

…………………………………………………

Title:  “A Letter From Home”
Scientist: AGNES BORTHWICK
Composed by: All Saints Primary P6A
Words: based on a prize winning poem by Jessie Duffton published in the Georgetown Gazette (1916) alongside various other extracts anonymous poems and articles
Written in: Jan – March 2019
Arranged by: Frances M Lynch & Herbie Clarke
For: voices & guitar
Performed by: All Saints Primary P6 & Herbie Clarke (guitar)
First Performed:  Beacon Arts Centre, Greenock, Scotland March 8th 2019 as part of “ECHOES FROM INVERCLYDE” by ELECTRIC VOICE THEATRE

Like the previous song – this one is a live recording. It was inspired in the same way and like the previous song was created by the composers choosing scraps of text and pictures from the magazines of the Georgetown Munitions Factory. The children really got to grips with life in this factory, and it’s clear from their songs that they were excited to bring the words and stories of these women engineers to life.

YOU CAN FIND THE LYRICS OF BOTH SONGS HERE ON A PDF

…………………………………………………………

Title: Forgetting to Remember – WW1 Women in Engineering
Composer:  FRANCES M LYNCH
Words by: Christina Rossetti, Frances M Lynch, George V, King of England, Women Engineers from WW1
Written: Feb 2019
For: A cappella female voices
Performed by: Clydeside Singers, Margaret Cameron (mezzo)  and Frances M Lynch
First Performed:  Beacon Arts Centre, Greenock, Scotland March 8th 2019 as part of “ECHOES FROM INVERCLYDE” by ELECTRIC VOICE THEATRE

It was written in collaboration with Science Historian Catherine Booth and Women in Engineering expert Nina Baker as a celebration of 100 years since the birth of the Women in Engineering Society.

The music begins with a 4 part prelude from Rossetti’s poem “Remember” and the relentless ostinato that follows is overlaid with words by women working in engineering during world war one and a speech made by the King alongside a list of women’s names from South West Scotland who we were able to find in the records, including the women at Georgetown Munitions Factory.

“I am using my life’s energy to destroy human souls.  I’m doing what I can to bring this to an end.

But once the War is over, I will never do the same again.” Anonymous in a munitions factory magazine

Education

Honours MA degree from Glasgow University in 1912. Was awarded research scholarship, and spent 2 years in the USA, at Bryn Mawr College, then the University of Columbia, New York, and Radcliffe College, Cambridge, Mass. She returned to the UK around the time of the outbreak of war.

In 1915, Agnes volunteered following an appeal from the Ministry of Munitions for women workers. She undertook training at Woolwich, for which she obtained a first class certificate.

Occupations

The Minister of Munitions Winston Churchill is escorted through the yard of Georgetown’s filling works near Glasgow by female workers during a visit on 9 October 1918. Copyright: © IWM. Original Source: http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205022561

Forewoman in Munitions Factory

Working in the Munitions Factory at Georgetown near Paisley, with supervisory responsibilities. She was sent to the factory shortly after it was established, so her first jobs would have involved preparing the new factory buildings – scrubbing and cleaning, and unloading shell casings. The women worked in shifts of 8 and three-quarter hours, and either commuted from neighbouring towns, or lived in hostels on site.

Works Manager in Munitions Factory

In July 1916, she was appointed Works Manager, at the top of the management structure, reporting only to the General Manager of the factory, and in charge of the shell and cartridge filling industrial plants.  By the end of the war, the Factory employed over

14,000 workers, mainly women, and Agnes was in charge of at least half of them.  Their work involved transporting and preparing empty casings, filling, packing and transporting 18-pound shells and cartridges of all sizes

Factory workers at Georgetown. Some are clearly wearing their triangular ‘On War Service’ badge. (Reproduced with permission of NLS from: Official history of the Scottish Filling Factory … Georgetown (1919))

Scientific Achievements

  • She played a prominent role in the essential manufacture of munitions for use in WW1. Her job would have required her to understand engineering processes, have expertise in the handling of high explosives, employ and train inexperienced staff, and have a thorough knowledge of health and safety procedures, alongside the responsibility for the efficient supply of ammunition for the war effort. High importance was put on the welfare of the employees, and they were relatively well paid.
  • In a few months she helped develop the factory from a few sheds to a large industrial complex. By the end of the war, the total number of shells filled at the Factory was over 19 million, and the number of cartridges filled totalled over 27 million.

Did You Know?

The knitted facemasks (respirators) worn by the women in the factory. The cross let them know which side was to be worn next to the face. (Reproduced by, and with permission of, the National Library of Scotland from: Official history of the Scottish Filling Factory … Georgetown (1919))

  • Because the factory buildings covered a large area, and managers had to move between buildings as part of their normal work, it was sometimes difficult to find Agnes or her fellow managers at headquarters when they were needed.  A whistle-call system was introduced, with a distinct call being allocated to each manager. So, if Agnes were to hear her own call, she would locate the nearest telephone, and contact headquarters to find out what the problem was.
  • Those working with toxic substances in the factory such as TNT, were issued with face masks, called ‘Georgetown respirators’.  Incredibly these were hand-knitted to a specific design.  They covered the mouth and nose, and had elastic ear loops. Each day, they were washed in boiling water and ironed to sterilise them. Eventually one unidentified village in Scotland supplied nearly all the respirators for the factory.
  • In 1918, the workers at the factory raised £2,500 from their own pockets to buy and donate to the Royal Air Force a fully equipped battle plane, named after the factory.  This went into active service in France.

The ‘Georgetown’ battleplane (Reproduced by, and with permission of, the National Library of Scotland from: Official history of the Scottish Filling Factory … Georgetown (1919))

  • The employees at Georgetown contributed to a fund to support anyone who was ill, or had suffered an accident. They also raised funds for the Red Cross, and responded to appeals for help in knitting socks for soldiers, and sewing overalls for nurses on war service.
  • Georgetown workers campaigned vociferously for their industrial complex to be retained after the war as a permanent garden city, with factories and nearby housing for workers in healthy surroundings. Their deputation failed, and thefactory buildings were demolished and the contents put up for sale, including furniture, fittings, machine tools, catering equipment and even two pianos.

An Inspiring Woman

Quote from: McLaren, Barbara. Women of the war. London; New York : Hodder and Stoughton, 1917: “No woman’s work has more directly furthered the prosecution of the war than that of Miss Agnes Borthwick, who within one year has risen to the unique position – for a woman – of works manager in a great Munitions Factory.”

It was rare in her day for any woman to be appointed to the top level of management in industry, and it seems that Agnes Borthwick became the most senior female munitions factory manager in the whole of the UK.

After the war, Agnes Borthwick married a mining engineer, Symington Macdonald, and brought up a family. There is no record of her continuing with a professional career.

Links